Carmel-by-the-Sea Gift Guide: Our Local Favorites

There’s something magical about holiday shopping in Carmel-by-the-Sea. The twinkling lights, the charming courtyards, the scent of cedar and sea salt in the air—it all adds up to a shopping experience unlike anywhere else

Our team took a stroll through town to hand-pick some of our favorite local gifts. From handcrafted candles to cozy apparel to unique treats you won’t find anywhere else, these twelve ideas showcase the heart and creativity of our local merchants.

Below are each team member’s picks—curated with love, wrapped with Carmel charm, and ready to delight everyone on your list.

Nicollette’s Picks

1. Big Sur After Rain Candle – Somewhere in Carmel
"There are few things more soothing than the woodsy aroma of Big Sur after a rainfall. Hand-poured and richly scented, it brings the calm and beauty of the Central Coast indoors—a sensory escape that is always available and never gets old."

2. Fun & Sturdy Toy Cars – Starchild
"Bright, bold, and built to last, these colorful toy cars spark imagination and plenty of high-speed play. They’re a sweet, nostalgic gift that kids will love, and parents will appreciate their quality and durability. My boys absolutely love them."

3. Tennis Ball Dog Toys – Diggidy Dog
"These Carmel-themed tennis balls make the perfect gift for the four-legged friends in your life. Durable and playful, they’re great for fetch sessions on Carmel Beach or backyard playtime all year long. I always carry one around for my pups."

4. Shoes, Accessories, Art – House of Cardoon
"House of Cardoon is known for its stylish and eclectic finds—like these cute and bold cowboys boots. It’s the perfect stop for a fashion-forward gift with personality, the kind that gets shown off and starts conversations time and time again."

Charlotte’s Picks

1. Geranium & Tomato Leaf Candle – Tancredi & Morgen
"Tancredi & Morgen is possibly the best kept secret of the Peninsula. European imports of all things lovely! My personal favorites are their candles — either the Santa Rosa Mexican Church candles or their specialty Geranium and Tomato Leaf. Get them before they sell out!"

2. Stationery, Pens, Books – The Pleasure of Writing
"Nothing compares to receiving a handwritten note. This tiny little shop is a great resource for a lovely gift of stationery, pens, and journals."

3. Bath & Body Products – Elizabeth W
"This small store in the heart of downtown Carmel has a huge selection of unique, special gifts. The Vetiver or Magnolia Bath Fizz Tablets are two favorites that make a winter soak special."

4. Books, Toys, Small Gifts – Carmel Bay Company
"Carmel Bay Company is a Carmel staple! A reliable source for unique gifts. Local Carmel books are a fun choice!"

5. Sustainable Apparel and Accessories – Inspired Muse
"A special shoutout to new (first year in Carmel) shop. All sustainable, mindful product lines...I find something special every time I am there!"

Dillon’s Picks

1. Swedish Candy – Sea Shack
"These colorful Swedish candies are impossible to resist and always a treat. They make a great stocking stuffer—or a sweet pick-me-up for yourself during holiday errands. Walking into this newly opened shop is always a good time. The Bufkins have created a must-stop shop for all your candy needs."

2. Fine Jewelry & Watches – Fourtane
"Fourtane is known for their exceptional, curated selection of fine jewelry and luxury timepieces. A gift from this renowned shop is timeless, elegant, and deeply meaningful—perfect for marking a milestone or creating a holiday memory that lasts."

3. Apparel & Accessories – Carmel Surf Shop
"As local as it gets. This shop has everything you need for the surfer or ocean enthusiast in your life. Apparel from the Carmel Surf Shop — like their logo sweatshirts that come in many colors — is as comfortable as it is iconic. Even for those who don't surf, it's a great way to celebrate something that is a big cultural piece of Carmel."

4. Home Furnishings – Carmel Home Collection
"For the design-lover on your list, Carmel Home Collection offers beautiful, coastal-inspired furnishings and textiles. The decorative pillows shown in our picks add warmth and charm to any space, making them a thoughtful and elegant home gift."

Wrapping Up

Carmel-by-the-Sea is filled with incredible artists, shopkeepers, and makers who pour their passion into every product. Shopping local not only supports these small businesses — it allows us to give gifts filled with authenticity, craftsmanship, and the spirit of our seaside village. We hope this guide inspires you to explore, discover, and share the magic of Carmel this season.